Exclusive: All Quiet on the Northern Front: Texas FTZs vs. North Dakota

FTZ News: In Fargo, a Trade Zone Shrinks. In Texas, the Machine Keeps Humming. Federal data show North Dakota's busiest foreign-trade zone shed most of its reported workforce in a single year, while the nation's largest zone network kept its grip on the top spot.
FARGO, N.D.—For more than a decade, a farm-equipment maker gave this prairie city an outsize role in a little-known federal trade program.
In 2009, regulators cleared CNH to build agricultural tractors and construction wheel loaders under foreign-trade-zone rules here. By 2012 the facilities employed 761 people and could turn out up to 7,200 tractors a year.
The latest federal tally tells a different story. The Foreign-Trade Zones Board puts 2024 employment at Fargo's zone, FTZ 267, at 151 to 250 workers. A year earlier, it was 1,251 to 1,500. Merchandise received fell to between $100 million and $250 million, from $500 million to $750 million.
Roughly a thousand miles south, the picture couldn't be more different. Texas ran 35 approved zones in 2024, more than any other state. They shipped $25 billion to $50 billion in exports and employed about 65,000 people.
The gap is wide. The more telling question is why.
Why It Matters
Foreign-trade zones are secure sites under U.S. Customs and Border Protection supervision. Goods inside them are treated, for duty purposes, as if they haven't yet entered the country.
That lets companies defer duties, pay lower rates on finished products than on parts, or skip duties entirely on goods re-exported. Congress created the program in 1934 to blunt the Smoot-Hawley tariffs. With tariffs again reshaping supply chains, the old tool has fresh relevance.
Nationally, zones took in $963.8 billion in merchandise in 2024 and exported $133.5 billion. Nearly 543,000 people worked at about 1,300 active zone operations. Those are the latest full-year figures; the Board's 2024 report was published in December 2025.
By the Numbers Zone figures are for 2024 and appear in ranges, because the Board protects company data. Statewide trade figures are full-year federal data.
| Category | Texas | North Dakota |
|---|---|---|
| First zone approved | FTZ 12, McAllen, 1973 (nation's first inland zone) | FTZ 103, Grand Forks, April 1984 |
| Approved zones, 2024 | 35 (most of any state) | 2 (Grand Forks; Fargo, est. 2006) |
| Zones reporting activity, 2024 | Statewide network active | 1 of 2 (Grand Forks reported none) |
| Merchandise received by zones, 2024 | More than $100 billion | $100 million–$250 million |
| Exports from zones, 2024 | $25 billion–$50 billion | $5 million–$10 million |
| Zone employment, 2024 | 65,001–66,000 | 151–250 |
| National rank in zone exports, 2024 | No. 1, in both production and warehousing | Not ranked |
| Main zone production | Oil refining, LNG, petrochemicals | Tractors and wheel loaders (CNH); absent from 2024 tables |
| Statewide goods exports, 2025 | $448.2 billion (No. 1 state) | $8.7 billion (No. 35) |
| Statewide goods imports, 2024 | $397.2 billion | About $4.0 billion (Jan.–Nov.) |
| Top export markets, 2025 | Mexico $124.7B (28%), Canada $34.8B, Netherlands $31.6B | Canada $7.0B (81%), Mexico $819M, Australia $164M |
| Leading manufactured exports, 2025 | Computers/electronics $70.7B, petroleum and coal $67.6B, chemicals $55.1B | Petroleum and coal $3.8B, nonelectrical machinery $1.0B, chemicals $434M |
| Zone exports vs. state exports (rough) | About 6%–11% | About 0.06%–0.11% |
The last row divides 2024 zone exports by 2025 state exports, so treat it as an order of magnitude, not a precise share.
Origins: A Border Town and Two Airports
Texas got in early. McAllen's FTZ 12, created in 1973, was the country's first inland zone, built on farmland near the Mexican border. Port, border and energy zones followed in the decades after.
North Dakota came later and stayed smaller. Grand Forks won approval in 1984. Fargo followed with a grant in January 2006. Both zones are run by local bodies: Fargo's by its municipal airport authority, Grand Forks's by a regional economic-development group.
Footprint: 35 Zones Versus Two
Texas's 35 zones stretch from El Paso to the Gulf Coast. Many carry subzones for single companies, from ExxonMobil to LNG terminals in the Port Arthur area.
North Dakota has two general-purpose zones. Fargo also hosts a subzone for Digi-Key Corp., an electronic-components distributor, approved in 2018. In 2024, all of the state's reported activity came from Fargo.
Merchandise In: Billions Versus Millions
Texas zones received more than $100 billion in goods in 2024. North Dakota's received $100 million to $250 million.
A caution: "merchandise received" isn't the same as imports. Nationally, about two-thirds of it carried domestic status. At production sites the figure was 80%. The Board doesn't publish foreign-status receipts by state.
Statewide, the contrast holds. Texas imported $397.2 billion in goods in 2024. North Dakota imported about $4 billion in the first 11 months.
Exports: Where the Gap Widens
Texas zones exported $25 billion to $50 billion in 2024, first among states. Border zones dominated warehouse-and-distribution exports: El Paso's FTZ 68 ranked third nationally and FTZ 150 fourth. McAllen was seventh, Brownsville eighth and Laredo 14th. Liberty County, Houston and DFW Airport also made the top 25.
North Dakota's zones exported $5 million to $10 million.
Scale explains part of that, but not all. Texas's economy dwarfs North Dakota's. Even so, zone exports equal roughly 6% to 11% of Texas's goods exports. In North Dakota, they're about a tenth of 1%.
Jobs: 65,000 Versus a Few Hundred
Texas zones employed 65,001 to 66,000 people in 2024. The state leads the nation in zone employment, alongside Arizona and California.
North Dakota's zones employed 151 to 250. That's the year's starkest number. It also marks a drop of roughly 85% from 2023.
Production: Refineries Versus Tractors
Nationally, production drives the program. It accounted for 61% of zone merchandise and 82% of zone jobs in 2024.
Texas's production heft sits on the Gulf. Corpus Christi's FTZ 122 and Port Arthur's FTZ 116 ranked second and third in Site Selection magazine's index of 2024 zone impact. Houston's FTZ 84 ranked fifth. The work there is refining, liquefied natural gas and petrochemicals.
North Dakota's production story was CNH. Its tractor and wheel-loader authority no longer appears in the 2024 tables. The Board doesn't say why.
Destinations: Mexico Versus Canada
The Board doesn't track where zone exports go. Statewide data offer a proxy.
Texas sells to the world, with Mexico first at $124.7 billion in 2025, or 28% of its goods exports. Canada, the Netherlands, South Korea and Japan follow.
North Dakota sells to its northern neighbor. Canada bought $7 billion, or 81%, of the state's 2025 goods exports. Mexico was a distant second at $819 million.
What the Data Can't Say
The numbers leave three questions open.
First, why Fargo fell. The report doesn't say whether CNH moved production, scaled back its zone use or changed how it reports.
Second, the precision. Every state and zone figure is a range, so small swings can look large and large ones can hide inside a band.
Third, the mix of years. Zone data run through 2024; the latest statewide export data cover 2025. Comparisons across the two are rough by design.
The Bottom Line
An approved zone is a license, not a guarantee. Texas paired its licenses with ports, pipelines and border crossings, and built a business base that uses them at scale.
North Dakota has the same federal tools. For now, the latest data point to a program that rests on one city, and one that just lost most of its reported workforce./.
