Italy’s ZES Unica vs. Malaysia’s JS-SEZ: European Differences, Asian Similarities

Rome subsidizes machinery in its poorer South. Johor is betting on a low tax rate and an easier Causeway...
FTZ News: Italy folded eight regional zones into one on Jan. 1, 2024, and aimed the result at its poorer South. A year later, Malaysia and Singapore signed a pact covering about 3,500 square kilometers of southern Johor. Both promise faster permits and cheaper capital. The similarity ends about there.
Italy's zone covers the eight regions of the Mezzogiorno, from Abruzzo down to Sicily and Sardinia. Since November 2025 it also stretches over Marche and Umbria, which sit in the country's center. Johor's zone lies wholly inside Malaysia, spread across nine flagship areas, among them the Pengerang petrochemical complex. The land is Malaysian, and Singapore's part is mostly capital and know-how.
By the count of Confindustria, the employers' group, and SRM, a bank-backed research center, Italy had issued 1,402 single authorizations by mid-2026, tied to €9.2 billion of direct investment and about 24,600 direct jobs. Malaysia and Singapore report RM88.83 billion, roughly S$28 billion, approved since January 2025, with 45% implemented and 28,755 jobs expected. Approvals aren't cash out the door, and nobody's payroll includes those jobs yet.
Italy's carrot is a tax credit on new machinery and plant, for projects of €200,000 to €100 million, with €2.3 billion set aside for 2026, €1 billion for 2027 and €750 million for 2028. Demand has outrun the money. For 2025 investments, the Revenue Agency granted about 60% of the credit companies requested; a later top-up lifted that to as much as 75%. The credit doesn't require a single authorization, so the two sets of numbers only partly overlap.
Malaysia dangles a tax rate instead: 5% for up to 15 years on qualifying new investment, against a standard 24%, plus a flat 15% personal rate for a decade for eligible knowledge workers. It can't be stacked with pioneer status.
Customs breaks are scarcer than the "special zone" label implies. Italian law lets authorities carve out enclosed customs free zones, mostly in ports, where duties and VAT on goods from outside the EU are suspended.
Johor's relief is mostly paperwork. Since January 2025, traders moving goods by land need one transshipment permit from Singapore Customs instead of two. Separately, passport-free QR clearance at Singapore's land checkpoints, in place since March 2024, has eased congestion, Enterprise Singapore says. Goods made wholly in Johor still don't count as Singapore-origin. That takes roughly 25% local content, or substantial transformation, in Singapore, according to the law firm Trowers & Hamlins.
Neither zone reports trade for its own footprint, so regional figures have to do. The Mezzogiorno sold about €64.1 billion abroad in 2025, roughly a tenth of Italy's total and 1.2% less than a year earlier, even as the national figure grew. Sicily and Sardinia lean on refined oil, Campania on chemicals and pharmaceuticals, Basilicata on cars from Melfi. Basilicata's exports fell 17.8% to €1.3 billion, a drop Il Sole 24 Ore largely ties to the Stellantis plant there.
Johor accounted for 19.8% of Malaysia's exports in 2025, second to Penang's 38.1%, led by refined petroleum and electronics. On imports it ranked third, at 22.3%, behind Selangor and Penang. State-level destination data weren't available. Nationally, ASEAN took 29% of Malaysia's exports in the first nine months of 2025, the U.S. 14% and China 12%.
Italy casts a wide net. Agrifood makes up 24% of authorizations, aerospace and biotech 1%, and Campania and Puglia scooped up more than 70%. Johor's shopping list is shorter: AI and quantum supply chains, medical devices, aerospace, specialty chemicals, logistics. Last year the state led Malaysia in approved investment, at RM110 billion.
Johor's master plan has slipped, there's no single regulatory framework, and the Causeway still jams. Maybank analysts put the state's median wage at about a seventh of Singapore's, so workers keep crossing for the paycheck. A rail link to Singapore is due at the end of December, the month the two prime ministers are scheduled to meet.
The harder question is whose investment wouldn't have come anyway.
Luca Bianchi of the research institute Svimez argues Italy's zone mostly reinforces what already exists. Confindustria and SRM say it activates new capacity, and put its total impact, indirect effects included, at roughly €58 billion to €59 billion. Johor's approvals show what was signed, not what would have landed there regardless. None of the data reviewed here settles it.
